Best Eye Cream for Sensitive Skin – November, 2018 Reviews & Buyers Guide of the Top Products

It is needless to say that your skin is the first point of defense for your entire body. There are plenty of areas on your skin that are quite sensitive. This is especially true for the area around your eyes. If otherwise, your skin is quite hardy, you may experience additional sensitivity to sunlight, as well as, skin care creams and lotions around your eyes. It is essential for you to remember that even the best eye cream can treat some of the skin problems around your eyes. Thus, before you even decide to choose such a product, better find out for sure about the skin issue you wish to target with such a product.

There are several types of skin problems that may appear around your eyes. Some of the major and most common ones have been listed below.

  • Wrinkles and Fine Lines: These usually form above your cheekbones and in the creases of your eyes. You may not know, but it is true that the skin around your eyes moves as frequently as the skin around your mouth. Remember all those times when you had to squint your eyes in bright sunlight or had to make a facial expression.
  • Puffiness and Redness: These problems usually take place when there are fluids beneath your eyes. Even though it may sound a bit strange to you, it is quite normal for such skin problems to take place.
  • Dark Circles under Your Eyes: This is basically a symptom that is usually associated with lack of proper and adequate hours of sleep. However, there are some people who are genetically predisposed to getting dark circles. Sometimes, these skin problems around your eyes may also prove that either blood has built up in the region or the skin around those areas is exceptionally thin.
  • Irritation or Sensitivity: This problem usually takes place if you use any skin care product that has fragrances or any reactive ingredients.
  • Dryness: This problem may lead to highest levels of irritation along with the appearance of flaky or red skin near your eyes.

You will come across several over the counter best drugstore eye cream that can prove useful in treating all of these above-discussed skin problems. These products prove useful if you have healthy skin with not much of a history of skin sensitivity. However, if your skin is exceptionally sensitive, then you may also experience adverse reactions to those products that may prove useful to others.

Information Every Informed Buyer Should Know When Looking For an Eye Cream for Sensitive Skin

It is obvious that if you suffer from dark circles around your eyes, you will certainly not use an eye cream for sensitive eyes that also deal with wrinkles. If your skin is extremely sensitive, you will always want to choose the best eye cream for sensitive skin that can provide excellent care, and that will not give rise to new and unnecessary problems due to active ingredients.

It is good for you to know that most of the skin problems around your eyes can easily be cured if you can get proper hours of sleep. If you get exhausted, it will naturally increase the appearance of various characteristics such as dark under eye circles or puffiness. However, getting proper sleep may not be the only cause for such problems. Thus, proper sleep with the suitable care of your skin around your eyes with the best drugstore eye cream for sensitive skin will be a good way to tackle such problems.

Best Eye Cream for Sensitive Skin

Our Favorite
Queen Bee Naturals Best Eye Balm Peeper Keeper - Eyelid Cream Helps Reduce Crows Feet, Wrinkles & Fine Lines - Pure Anti Aging Restorative Moisturizes Your Skin - Vitamin E + 10 Organic Nutrient Oils
The packaging of the Queen Bee Naturals Peeper Keeper Eye Balm is such that one purchase will last you for a long time.
$15.74
Highest Rated
Simple Soothing Eye Balm, 0.5 Ounce
The Pure Soothing Eye Balm is one of the best moisturizer product for your skin, and it does not contain a lot of ingredients.
$9.87
Highest Quality
Murad Renewing Eye Cream, 0.5 Fluid Ounce
Murad is one of those manufacturers of skincare products that has a long list of serums, cleansers, supplements, and masks that are specially designed to deal with various types of skin related issues.
$61.19
Baebody Eye Gel for Appearance of Dark Circles, Puffiness, Wrinkles and Bags. - for Under and Around Eyes - 1.7 fl oz.
It contains plant stem cells that are helpful in enhancing the overall resistance to sun damage and strength of your skin.
$23.95
B00LV6VDG2
Eye Cream Moisturizer (1oz) 94% Natural Anti Aging Skin Care
If you are searching for a sensitive eye cream that deals with most of the skin problems around your eyes, then the LilyAna Naturals Rosehip and Hibiscus Eye Cream Moisturizer will be a good option.
$19.99
Era Organics Natural Face Moisturizer Cream - Advanced 10-In-1 Non Greasy Daily Facial Cream with Aloe Vera, Manuka Honey, Coconut Oil, Cocoa Butter and More For Oily, Dry, Sensitive Skin (2oz)
Era Organics claims that this product is a “superfood” for your skin. It contains a long list of ingredients such as vitamin B, Manuka honey, blue and green algae, and hemp seed oil.
$17.32
Amara Organics Eye Cream Gel for Dark Circles and Puffiness with Peptides.5 fl. oz.
Although the Amara Organics Total Repair Eye Gel is useful in treating more than the dark circles around your eyes, the other benefits are merely results of the way the product works on your skin.
$15.95
Neutrogena Hydro Boost Hydrating Gel Eye Cream with Hyaluronic Acid, Dermatologist Recommended, Oil and Fragrance Free, 0.5 fl. oz
Unlike the other Hydro Boost line of products, Neutrogena designed this eye gel to be extra gentle in order to be used near your eyes. You may also use it along with your lash lines or on your eyelids.
$13.19
Burt's Bees Eye Cream for Sensitive Skin, 0.5 Ounces
This will make you familiar to their all natural ingredients that are also used in their Burt’s Bees Eye Cream. This is also the primary reason why this skincare product is best suited for sensitive skin types.
$14.99
Perricone MD Hypoallergenic Firming Eye Cream, 0.5 fl. oz.
This skincare product contains ingredients that are mainly extracted from plants such as olive leaf and olive fruit extracts.
$41.80

Queen Bee Naturals Peeper Keeper Eye Balm

The packaging of the Queen Bee Naturals Peeper Keeper Eye Balm is such that one purchase will last you for a long time. On the other hand, there are several skin care products that come in small packages and need to be often replaced. Another added benefit of the product is that it can easily deal with a wide array of skin related problems around your eye region. This is possible due to the natural ingredients that are used in this cream. It includes several plant extracts, oils, and vitamin E.

The formula used in the Queen Bee Naturals Peeper Keeper Eye Balm penetrates your skin very easily and nourishes it from deep inside. This helps you fight against several skin problems such as redness, fine lines, puffiness, and dryness.

Simply apply the cream to your skin around the eye region after cleansing. Do not make the mistake of bringing the cream in contact with your eyes.

Pros and Cons

  • The Queen Bee Naturals Peeper Keeper Eye Balm lasts for a really long time, and there is no need for you to buy it frequently.
  • It can easily deal with a range of eye area skin problems.
  • The application can prove to be a bit oily.
See Product Details on Amazon

Pure Soothing Eye Balm

The Pure Soothing Eye Balm is one of the best moisturizer product for your skin, and it does not contain a lot of ingredients. This will be a great option if you wish to use a skin care product that is a to-the-point product and can relieve you from puffiness and dry eyes. It contains a blend of jojoba oil and shea butter that can hydrate and soothe your skin. This blend can also add vital vitamins to your skin in order to nourish it properly.

The Pure Soothing Eye Balm does not come with any fragrance and is also free from dyes. In order to use it, gently smooth the product onto your eye areas till it blends thoroughly.

Pros and Cons

  • The price of the Pure Soothing Eye Balm is affordable.
  • If you use it as a pure moisturizer, it can prove to be very useful.
  • It is not useful in treating severe skin concerns.
See Product Details on Amazon

Murad Renewing Eye Cream

Murad is one of those manufacturers of skincare products that has a long list of serums, cleansers, supplements, and masks that are specially designed to deal with various types of skin related issues. There are numerous salons and spas that use and also trust the products made by Murad. If you are a bit hesitant in trying out a new brand of skin care product, you can easily use Murad’s products that are well-established.

There are several skin care products, such as the Murad Renewing Eye Cream, that are sold by the manufacturer as an anti-aging product. This cream is specially designed to provide some brightness to the dark circles around your eyes and to bring back your natural youthful glow on your skin. This cream also has a clinically proven rejuvenating peptide that helps to reduce the appearance of fine lines and wrinkles and boost the firmness of your skin.

In order to use it, gently massage a small portion of the Murad Renewing Eye Cream beneath your eyes till it gets fully absorbed. You can use this product once you are done using your toning and cleansing products. You can also use a moisturizer after using the Murad Renewing Eye Cream to maximize the results.

Pros and Cons

  • Murad Renewing Eye Cream helps to lower the various symptoms of aging such as dark circles and crow’s feet.
  • It happens to be a salon brand product that even professionals trust.
  • Since it is a salon brand product, it also comes with a salon brand price tag.
See Product Details on Amazon

BAEBODY Beauty Eye Gel

The skincare products made by BAEBODY Beauty are branded by the manufacturer as “the art and science of skincare.” You will understand the reason behind this claim once you take a closer look at the ingredients used in the making of their BAEBODY Beauty Eye Gel. It contains plant stem cells that are helpful in enhancing the overall resistance to sun damage and strength of your skin. It also contains Matrixyl 3000 that is rather helpful in boosting the natural collagen production process of your skin to almost double its normal rate. It also protects your skin from all the free radicals that can easily cause fine lines and wrinkles on your skin.

All the active ingredients used in the making of the BAEBODY Beauty Eye Gel supercharges your skin. Whether you suffer from puffy eyes or dark spots or crow’s feet or dry skin, this skincare product is capable of dealing with all of these problems. This product comes with no filler ingredients and does not have any fragrance. The best part is that you can easily apply this cream under your normal makeup without getting the usual greasy and messy look.

All you have to do is pat the product gently on your eye, cheek, and forehead areas. You need to do so twice every day. You may also use this product as a full facial treatment.

Pros and Cons

  • The BAEBODY Beauty Eye Gel comes with a unique blend of several ingredients that sets the product apart from other products in the same category.
  • It is designed to target several skin related problems around your eyes.
  • The beads are easily biodegradable.
  • It may be a bit difficult to understand how your skin will react to the unique blend of several active ingredients in the product.
See Product Details on Amazon

LilyAna Naturals Rosehip and Hibiscus Eye Cream Moisturizer

If you are searching for a sensitive eye cream that deals with most of the skin problems around your eyes, then the LilyAna Naturals Rosehip and Hibiscus Eye Cream Moisturizer will be a good option. It basically has a “fix all” approach and is rather helpful in maintaining a hydrated and healthy skin around your eyes. The ingredients in this product do all the heavy lifting of the skin in your eye areas.

Rosehip seed oil helps to stimulate the natural ability of your skin to regenerate, and it also reduces the appearance of wrinkles and discoloration. On the other hand, the hibiscus flower extract provides proper nourishment to your skin in order to promote a firm surface and also to improve the natural elasticity of your skin.

The LilyAna Naturals Rosehip and Hibiscus Eye Cream Moisturizer is USDA organic certified and is 100% cruelty-free. Simply apply the cream in small dots beneath your eyebrows on the upper eyelid, as well as, below your eyes. Make sure that you do not apply it too close to your eyes. Pat in milk gently until it gets absorbed completely.

Pros and Cons

  • It can easily be applied to deal with under eye bags or wrinkles, and it happens to be one of the best eye wrinkle cream for sensitive skin.
  • It contains all natural vegan ingredients.
  • You need to give the product some time in order to set before you can put on any makeup.
See Product Details on Amazon

Era Organics 10-in1 Complete Facial Moisturizer

Era Organics claims that this product is a “superfood” for your skin. It contains a long list of ingredients such as vitamin B, Manuka honey, blue and green algae, and hemp seed oil. You may think that all of these ingredients may aggravate the sensitivity of your skin. On the contrary, the Era Organics 10-in1 Complete Facial Moisturizer’s hypoallergenic formula makes it suitable for sensitive skin of various types.

This simply means that the product will not just help your skin remain hydrated for almost 12 hours, it can also strengthen your skin, boost the growth of new skin cells, as well as, enhance the elasticity of your skin to deliver anti-aging effects. You may use this product all over your face, and the gentleness of the cream enables you to use it around your eyes also.

All you need to do is rub a dime-sized quantity of the Era Organics 10-in1 Complete Facial Moisturizer onto your skin until it gets absorbed completely.

Pros and Cons

  • Era Organics 10-in1 Complete Facial Moisturizer is a long-lasting moisturizer for your skin around your eyes.
  • It is made to match the pH level of your skin in order to minimize sensitivity.
  • Has a mild lingering fragrance.
  • It is basically an all facial moisturizer, which can also be used on the skin in your eye areas rather than made especially for the sensitive skin around your eyes.
See Product Details on Amazon

Amara Organics Total Repair Eye Gel

Although the Amara Organics Total Repair Eye Gel is useful in treating more than the dark circles around your eyes, the other benefits are merely results of the way the product works on your skin. The skincare product also minimizes sags and bags, as well as, tightens and brightens your skin beneath the eye area.

Before you decide to apply it make sure that your face is dry after you are done with the cleansing. Dab the product around your eyes.

Pros and Cons

  • Amara Organics Total Repair Eye Gel proves very useful when it comes to treating your tired and dark circles.
  • It easily removes your makeup and cleanses your facial skin in one single step.
  • The Amara Organics Total Repair Eye Gel does not provide an instant fix, and you need it to use it regularly to witness positive effects.
See Product Details on Amazon

Neutrogena Hydro Boost Eye Gel-Cream

Do you still use the best eye cream for sensitive skin 2016? Well, it is time to use the latest Neutrogena Hydro Boost Eye Gel-Cream. The Neutrogena Hydro Boost line of products includes three different products, out of which the Eye Gel-Cream is one of them. All of these products are designed with a single goal in mind, which is to lock in the natural moisture of your skin and also nourish your hydrated skin. This will help your skin to remain healthy and fresh instead of getting dried-out and appear dull.

One of the primary ingredients in the product is hyaluronic acid that is found naturally in your skin. The best part about it is that it can easily hold almost 1000 times its own weight in water and also deliver that moisture directly to the cells in your skin upon contact. Being one of the best under eye cream for sensitive skin, it also contains a small portion of olive extract that is rather helpful as a protective barrier for your skin. It shields your skin from losing moisture throughout the day.

Unlike the other Hydro Boost line of products, Neutrogena designed this eye gel to be extra gentle in order to be used near your eyes. You may also use it along with your lash lines or on your eyelids. The oil-free content will certainly not smear into your eyes while it dries. You may certainly not expect any type of irritation from it since it is free from any type of fragrance.

Simply apply the product to your dry eye areas before you put on any makeup and let it dry properly.

Pros and Cons

  • The Neutrogena Hydro Boost Eye Gel Cream can prove to be a good eye cream for dry, sensitive skin if you normally experience irritation or dryness near your eyes.
  • It is free from any type of fragrance.
  • It is one of the best eye cream for dry, sensitive skin and is gentle enough to be used every day.
  • If you experience multiple problems, then this product may not be suitable to deal with all of the issues.
See Product Details on Amazon

Burt’s Bees Eye Cream

You will find a variety of chapsticks and lip balms made by Burt’s Bees on the market that have made the manufacturer a household name. This will make you familiar to their all natural ingredients that are also used in their Burt’s Bees Eye Cream. This is also the primary reason why this skincare product is best suited for sensitive skin types.

There are several reasons that may make you search for a suitable skincare cream. These include wrinkles, eye bags, and dark circles to name a few. However, if you simply suffer from dry skin and mild puffiness or redness, you may not like to use skincare creams that come with a wide array of ingredients. In that case, the Burt’s Bees Eye Cream will be a great option for you. Simply use small dots of this cream all around your eyes and gently smooth.

Pros and Cons

  • If you already use their lip balm, then you will naturally feel more comfortable using the Burt’s Bees Eye Cream.
  • It is one of the best no-fuss moisturizing product for your skin.
  • It is not meant to deal with a wide array of skin problems.
See Product Details on Amazon

Perricone MD Hypoallergenic Firming Eye Cream

Most of you may think that a skincare product with MD on the label can never be gentle on your skin. Well, it is not true for this product. The Perricone MD Hypoallergenic Firming Eye Cream will give you the best possible results if you also consume nutritional supplements for your skin and also follow an anti-inflammatory diet. You simply have to apply the cream along the contours of your eye areas twice every day.

This skincare product contains ingredients that are mainly extracted from plants such as olive leaf and olive fruit extracts. These ingredients were patented by Dr. Perricone and are used in all their skincare products to give you benefits that are unique to their creams. This skin cream can provide a supreme level of hydration, which makes it suitable for users suffering from the extremely dry skin. You can also use it after cosmetic procedures without a major risk of adverse effects on your skin.

Pros and Cons

  • Perricone MD Hypoallergenic Firming Eye Cream is easily compatible with exceptionally dry skin.
  • It is gentle enough for you to use it even after your cosmetic procedures.
  • The formula used in this skincare product is patented.
  • The size of the package is pretty small, and you may have to buy it frequently.
See Product Details on Amazon

Final Thoughts

Whichever skincare product you choose, always make sure that before trying a new product make sure that you start with the minimal product in order to reduce any type of risks associated with skin irritations. It is also essential that you use your ring finger while applying any product around your eye area. The simple reason behind this statement is that your ring finger is the weakest and you will not be able to exert much pressure with it around your eyes.